Is Keto Healthy? What the Science Says (and Who It’s Not For)
Published:
The ketogenic diet—often shortened to keto—has become one of the most talked-about eating patterns of the last decade. Promoted for weight loss, better blood sugar control, and improved metabolic health, the keto diet is often framed as a universal solution.
But is keto healthy for everyone?
The short answer: it depends. Research suggests that while a ketogenic diet can offer health benefits for some people in specific situations, it may also increase health risks for others—especially when followed long term or without careful planning.
Let’s break down what the keto diet is, how it affects the body, and why it may not be the best choice for everyone’s overall health.
What Is the Ketogenic Diet?
Image from Tally Health
The ketogenic diet is a low carbohydrate, high fat diet designed to push the body into a metabolic state called nutritional ketosis. In this state, the body breaks down fat into ketone bodies for energy instead of relying primarily on glucose.
A typical keto diet includes:
Very low carbohydrate intake (often under 50 grams per day)
Moderate protein intake
High fat consumption, often including saturated fat
By drastically reducing carbs, the body lowers insulin levels, encouraging fat burning and ketone production. In other words, the body burns fat instead of carbohydrates.
Does the Keto Diet Help With Weight Loss?
Image from Tally Health
Many people do lose weight on keto—at least initially.
Research suggests that the keto diet reduces appetite, lowers insulin, and can lead to rapid early weight loss. Some people see improvements in body mass index (BMI) and blood glucose levels, especially those with insulin resistance or metabolic syndrome.
However, people lose weight on keto for several reasons, including:
Reduced daily calories due to appetite suppression
Loss of water weight from depleted glycogen stores
Increased fat oxidation (burning fat)
That said, meta analyses and literature reviews show that over the long term, weight loss on keto is often similar to other diets—including low calorie diets and Mediterranean-style diets—when calories and physical activity are matched.
Weight regain is also common once carbohydrate intake increases again.
Keto and Blood Sugar: Helpful, but Not Always Ideal
Image from Tally Health
A low carbohydrate diet can improve glycemic control and stabilize blood sugar in the short term, particularly for people with type 2 diabetes or carbohydrate intolerance.
By limiting carbohydrates, keto may reduce blood glucose spikes and lower insulin demand. This is one reason the keto diet is sometimes recommended in clinical settings.
However, chronically restricting carbs may also:
Reduce tolerance to carbohydrates over time
Impair insulin sensitivity in some individuals
Make blood sugar harder to regulate once carbs are reintroduced
For many people, moderate carb intake from whole grains, starchy vegetables, fruits, and legumes supports more flexible and sustainable blood sugar regulation.
Potential Health Risks of the Keto Diet
Image from Tally Health
While keto can offer benefits, it also comes with potential health risks, especially when followed long term.
1. Heart Health and Saturated Fat
The high fat nature of the keto diet often leads to increased intake of saturated fat, which research links to higher LDL cholesterol and a greater risk of cardiovascular disease in some individuals.
Although fats like olive oil and other unsaturated fats can support heart health, many keto diets rely heavily on butter, cream, and processed meats—foods associated with heart disease risk when consumed in excess.
Together, REM and NREM sleep repeat in four or five cycles per night, forming your overall sleep architecture.
2. Nutrient Deficiency
Eliminating or severely limiting carbohydrates can mean cutting out many nutrient-rich foods, including:
Whole grains
Fruits
Starchy vegetables
Certain legumes
Over time, this can increase the risk of nutrient deficiency, particularly fiber, magnesium, potassium, B-vitamins, and phytonutrients that support gut and cardiovascular health.
3. Gut Health and Microbiota
Fiber plays a key role in supporting a healthy gut microbiota. Very low carb diets often lack enough fiber, especially from vegetables and fruits, which can negatively impact digestion, immune function, and metabolic health.
Some people also experience an upset stomach, constipation, or bloating on keto.
4. Lean Mass Loss
Rapid weight loss on keto doesn’t always mean pure fat loss. Without adequate protein intake and physical activity, people may lose lean body mass along with fat—something that can negatively affect metabolic rate and long-term weight management.
5. The Keto Flu and Adaptation Stress
As the body transitions into ketosis, many people experience the so-called keto flu, which may include:
Fatigue
Headaches
Brain fog
Dizziness
Irritability
These symptoms occur as the body breaks its reliance on glucose and adapts to ketone production—a process that can be stressful, particularly for active individuals.
Is Keto Healthy Long Term?
Image from Tally Health
This is where the science becomes less convincing.
Most research showing benefits of keto is short term. Long-term studies suggest that strict carbohydrate restriction may increase health risks for some people, including:
Elevated cholesterol
Reduced metabolic flexibility
Higher cardiovascular disease risk
Difficulty maintaining a healthy weight over time
In contrast, diets with proven long-term benefits—like the Mediterranean diet—emphasize whole foods, healthy fats, enough carbs, and dietary variety.
Who Might Benefit From Keto?
The keto diet may help certain individuals under medical supervision, including:
People with specific neurological conditions (research has explored keto in epilepsy and Alzheimer’s disease)
Individuals with severe insulin resistance
Short-term metabolic interventions
But for most people seeking better overall health, cognitive performance, and sustainable fat loss, keto is not a one-size-fits-all solution.
A More Flexible Approach to Metabolic Health
Rather than eliminating carbs entirely, research suggests that many people benefit from:
Balanced low carb or moderate carb diets
Emphasizing non-starchy vegetables, leafy greens, and whole grains
Pairing carbohydrates with protein, fiber, and healthy fats
Supporting blood sugar with consistent meals and physical activity
This approach supports metabolic health without sacrificing nutrient diversity or long-term sustainability.
Is Keto Healthy?
Image from Tally Health
The keto diet works for some people—but it’s not universally healthy.
While keto can improve blood glucose and promote fat loss in the short term, it may also increase health risks, contribute to nutrient deficiencies, and be difficult to maintain long term. For many individuals, a more balanced, whole-food-based diet supports better heart health, cognitive function, and metabolic resilience over time.
When it comes to nutrition, the healthiest diet is one you can sustain—one that supports your biology, lifestyle, and long-term goals.
Support Metabolism—Without Extreme Diets
Image from Tally Health
Keto isn’t the only way to support metabolic health. Your body’s ability to produce energy, regulate blood sugar, and burn fat depends on more than cutting carbs—it relies on mitochondrial function, nutrient availability, and metabolic flexibility.
Amplify by Tally Health is a science-backed metabolic and energy supplement designed to support cellular energy production, healthy glucose metabolism, and sustained vitality—without extreme restriction. It complements balanced nutrition and daily movement to help your metabolism work with your body, not against it.
Is the keto diet healthy for everyone?
No. Research suggests that while the ketogenic diet can offer health benefits for some people in specific situations, it may increase health risks for others—especially when followed long term or without careful planning.
Does the keto diet help with weight loss?
Many people lose weight on keto initially due to reduced appetite, lower insulin levels, water weight loss, and increased fat burning. However, long-term weight loss is often similar to other diets when calories and activity are matched, and weight regain is common once carbs are reintroduced.
What are the potential health risks of the keto diet?
Potential risks include increased LDL cholesterol and cardiovascular risk from high saturated fat intake, nutrient deficiencies, poor gut health due to low fiber intake, lean muscle loss, and short-term symptoms like fatigue and brain fog during adaptation.
Chen et al. Ketogenic Diet and Multiple Health Outcomes: An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analysis. Nutrients 2023; Ketogenic Diet and Multiple Health Outcomes: An Umbrella Review of Meta-Analysis
Malinowska and Żendzian-Piotrowska. Ketogenic Diet: A Review of Composition Diversity, Mechanism of Action and Clinical Application. J Nutr Metab 2024; https://doi.org/10.1155/2024/6666171
Dyńka et al. Ketogenic Diets for Body Weight Loss: A Comparison with Other Diets. Nutrients 2025;
We noticed you have an existing account with Tally. Add products to your existing subscription by going to Manage My Plan within your Account settings.
Want more energy? This supplement is designed to boost metabolism and cellular energy while optimizing mitochondrial function.
What Amplify is made of:
Glycine
1,000mg
Berberine
600mg
Coenzyme Q10
200mg
What Amplify does:
Increases NAD+
Supports healthy metabolism
Boosts muscle recovery
Suggested Use:
Take three capsules daily, with food, to help promote metabolism and energy.
Meet Defend
Defend is designed to promote a healthy, vibrant immune system while simultaneously targeting immune-related aging hallmarks.
What Defend is made of:
Quercetin
500mg
Vitamin C
90mg
Beta-glucan
30mg
Zinc
11mg
Vitamin D3
1000IU
What Defend does:
Reduces inflammaging
Offer protection against acute respiratory infections
Help decrease the duration of respiratory infections
Stimulate the activity of white blood cells, which fight infection and repair normal cell function
Suggested Use:
Take 2 capsules daily with food (including a healthy fat).
Meet NAD+
NAD+ is designed to help elevate NAD+ levels to fuel key cellular functions that support healthy aging.
What NAD+ is made of:
Niacinamide
1000mg
What NAD+ does:
Promotes mitochondrial energy production and metabolism
Helps protect against oxidative stress
Maintains skin health
Supports sirtuin proteins
Suggested Use:
Take 2 capsules daily with food.
Meet Restore
Support healthy aging as you sleep. This supplement will help you fall asleep and stay asleep so you wake up refreshed and recharged.
What Restore is made of:
Magnesium bisglycinate chelate complex
250mg
L-theanine
200mg
Apigenin
50mg
What Restore does:
Enhances sleep quality
Makes it easier to fall asleep
Improves restless leg syndrome
Supports restorative sleep
Promotes relaxation
Helps relieve anxiety
Promotes a positive mood
Suggested Use:
As needed, take three capsules 30-60 minutes before bed.
Meet Sharpen
Sharpen is the key to unlock better memory, clearer thinking, and improved focus as you age. Keep your mind sharper, for longer.
What Sharpen is made of:
Taurine
1000mg
Choline
200mg
Vitamin B6
1.7mg
L-methylfolate
400mcg DFE
Vitamin B12
2.4mcg
What Sharpen does:
Supports long-term cognitive health, brain aging, and overall performance
Lowers a risk factor for dementia by decreasing homocysteine levels
Supports cholinergic signaling, essential for the encoding of memories
Promotes aspects of focus and performance
Suggested Use:
Take 2 capsules daily, with food.
Meet Vitality
Slow aging at a cellular level. This supplement is designed to target all 12 hallmarks of biological aging.
What Vitality is made of:
Calcium Alpha-Ketoglutarate
1,000mg
Quercetin
500mg
Trans-resveratrol
500mg
Fisetin
50mg
Spermidine
900mcg
What Vitality does:
Induces autophagy
Maintains your epigenome
Removes senescent “zombie” cells
Activates sirtuins and repair processes
Suggested Use:
Take four capsules daily, with food (preferably including a healthy fat), to help promote your body's defense against aging.
Membership Benefits
Every six months, we’ll send you a TallyAge™ Test to measure your progress and improve your personalized action plan. Along the way, we’ll send our daily Vitality supplement and help you make powerful changes to unlock deeper health and vitality, for an even better you.
Bi-Annual Testing
Simply swab your cheek and drop the test kit in your mailbox. Our lab team will take care of the rest. Our TallyAge™ metric, developed from the world’s most comprehensive DNA methylation dataset of adult cheek cells, is an indicator of how you're aging on a biological level.
Personalized Recommendations
The results are in. You’ll get accurate insights into your biological health and aging - plus, a personalized action plan that highlights the high impact changes you can make to your lifestyle and daily habits to slow aging. Each recommendation is backed by efficacy data from groundbreaking research. All available, at the touch of a button, through Tally Health’s intuitive digital platform.